top of page

Search Results

Search this site

65 results found with an empty search

  • Open source is a distribution strategy, not a business model

    Hi, I'm Khushi, and I lead the growth and marketing efforts at Streamline. Streamline is an icon and illustration library with a generous free tier. In fact, our free tier is even more generous than the paid tiers of some of our competitors! The story of Streamline Streamline's founder released an open-source UI icon set consisting of over a thousand icons. This set achieved tremendous success and eventually led him to achieve financial independence. Lots of backlinks According to SEMRush, Streamline has nearly 100k backlinks, and Ahrefs rates our domain with a score of 76. Open-source products typically ask users to provide a backlink when they use the product. Open-source strategy For any successful business, two key elements are necessary: an audience and a revenue strategy. By creating a (good!) open-source product, you can effectively address the first part of the equation. It's important to note that "free" and "open-source" are different concepts. Freemium models offer some free features but place restrictions, while open-source provides everything possible and more. Solving revenue Generating revenue becomes more challenging when users' needs are already met with a free product. Moreover, Streamline is not the only open-source product available in the market. Companies like Google and IBM are also competing for the same market share. The history and the future We observe an increasing number of companies developing a defensible strategy based on open-source. If the paid product focuses on managed services while the free product is self-hosted, an open-source offering effectively discourages newcomers from entering the market. Examples : Red Hat: For a long time, Red Hat sold services for open-source software and scaled it with human resources. Hadoop: The paid tier had more intellectual property than the open-source product, but scalability was challenging due to imperfect user experience. between the two products. Streamline: Streamline represents a third-generation open-source software. It builds differentiated intellectual property around the open-source core and offers differentiated open-core software as a service. (I use "open-core" because that's the most commonly used term to refer to Streamline). People pay for more than just support, as they gain access to the Figma plugin, Lucid plugin, a desktop app, and ten times more icons than the free tier provides. Distribution-first, not product-first Although this viewpoint may be controversial, I believe more founders should consider a distribution-first strategy rather than a product-first strategy. At the very least, this approach ensures that your company won't fizzle out in the early stages. Take Netflix as an example—its biggest growth driver is the fact that it comes pre-installed in set-top boxes. By solving the distribution aspect, you can buy time and gather more user feedback, which is essential for success! Thank you for reading! Disclaimer: Opinions, insights and everything is pretty much mine. So, take it with a grain of salt!

  • Simple guide to running your first in-product A/B test

    A while back, I had to run A/B tests to improve the activation rate. If you've never run in-product A/B tests before, it can be a little overwhelming so here's a simple guide on how to get started. The first test The first test we conducted showed a significant lift, increasing our core action from 14% to 21%. It was a tiny change, but it made a huge impact. And got buy-in to run more experiments. The second test After we working on activation, we went a bit deeper making sure each part of the funnel was tested. We found a user insight that we wanted to actively solve for. The result? If you look at the data below, you can see that the percentage of people that successfully went and selected a plan increased by 28%. And all other health metrics improved. The test concluded that if site traffic remained constant, we had improved trial starts by 6%. I also want to acknowledge that it was a relatively big change (involved positioning and messaging) that required a week of design and dev support. When we first launched the test variant, the test failed. So, we watched some Hotjar recordings. Discovered a few bugs and some design flaws. Everyone jumped in to help and we quickly fixed it. Had we lost faith in the test early on, we wouldn't have done anything to improve it. You can start via these 3 ways. I've over-simplified them so you know where to look and what to look for. Option 1 Step 1) Use a feature flagging tool like Flagr to conduct A/B tests. Developers will create two different environments (control and test). Step 2) Then send that data to Mixpanel, linked with the users' device IDs. Step 3) Next, analyze the data in Mixpanel. Mixpanel will directly calculate statistical significance for you, which is helpful. Option 2 Step 1) Send data from Segment directly to a tool like Statsig . Or via code. I chose Statsig because it was used by companies like Notion, Microsoft, Flipkart. It was self-serve (no need to speak to a sales rep to get started). They also offer a nice startup program if you wanted that? Statsig really speeds up the process of running experiments. You get to see all your metrics easily and can filter users with the user profile data that works best for you. I haven't completely explored the product myself, so it's a good idea to do some research on your own. In my own journey, I've evaluated Eppo, Optimizely, Taplytics, Split.io, and Launchdarkly. I finally chose Statsig. Step 2: Conduct experiments in Statsig. The process is similar: developers set up an experience, and you run a test, sending data to Statsig. Step 3: Then make a decision Option 3 Step 1) Utilize the experimentation tool in your analytics platform, like Mixpanel Experiments . Step 2) Ask developers to code the experience and run the test. What to test? To collect qualitative data for this test, I sent an email to users who signed up but did not activate in the product, asking for clear reasons why they didn't. It worked well but only after a bit of tweaking (adjust copy, timing etc). Here's the final template that worked well (h/t to Hillary for sharing): Subject : Brutal feedback for {company name} Body : Hi {first name}, I noticed that you signed up for {company name} but never did {core action}. Any chances you'd share why?—even a single sentence would go a long way in helping us improve the platform. Thanks! {founder's name} Founder at {company name} Start here with the user research if you want. Then validate with data. And finally, move on to building your test using the three options I shared above! Thanks for reading! Best, Khushi

  • Why do CMOs/Head of Growth have the shortest tenure?

    // This post has strong opinions that are loosely held. I also acknowledge that I'm taking inspiration from other industries which might not be accurate. But it's a starting point to solve an industry-wide problem we face. I'm open to feedback and suggestions. Everyone knows that marketing and growth teams are the first to be laid off. These teams have the shortest tenure in tech. Often times, they get fired because of one of these reasons: "The company has to pivot." "We have a retention problem." "Marketing can't acquire customers." "Growth can't grow revenue anymore." Not all layoffs are bad. Some are valid but there's a reason why marketers/growth people have the shortest tenures compared to other departments like product management, engineering, and customer success. I was inspired to find a solution and asked a few questions to myself: Are growth/marketers fluffy? Can they really not sell? Are they all words and no results? And assuming all of that is true, then Why is this the case? And what can we do about it? This investigation led me to explore whether the problem lies elsewhere? First, please walk with me through some examples. Then, I'll stitch everything together and share a hypothesis. #1 Intuit's most successful vs. a total failure ad Intuit is one of the most successful SaaS companies in the world with a valuation of $180 billion. Their earliest product was an accounting software. Campaign #1 To run a direct advertising campaign in PC Magazine, Intuit had to bet its entire net worth of $125,000. If it failed, the company would be bankrupt again (they had almost gone under twice before, and at one point, they had to stop paying employees' salaries). The founders wrote this direct response ad themselves after consulting with a marketing friend. Take a look at their old ad copy from 1986: The result? Huge success. The copy was drafted by Intuit's co-founder who had previously worked at Procter & Gamble. If you've got a few extra minutes, watch the interview below starting at the 33:42 mark. Campaign #2 Eventually, Intuit hired a marketing agency. This agency created a two-page ad featuring a bald lady who had seemingly pulled out all her hair doing accounting. Do you think it would perform well? Source: In$ide Intuit Book The ad was expensive to produce, with all the agency fees. Worse yet, it brought in a grand total of 4 (four!) customers of the millions of people that saw it. Yikes. No wonder the founders were upset. I think tech is relatively easy to sell. There's a clear value-exchange and risks are offset by a subscription business. "I think SaaS is beautiful because it's a pure value exchange between customer and company. And as long as the customer is receiving what they think is enough value, they'll continue to pay for your product. So it creates this really great incentivization structure for businesses to solve real problems." — Dave Burson, Head of Product, Growth & Monetisation at Canva Intuit built one of the best products. They became the market leader in 2 months. They had done lots of market research. If you watch the interview above, you'll see they mention 'research' in almost every 3rd sentence. Founder was ex-P&G and that marketing background is incredible. But who is to blame for the failed Intuit ad? The agency, the company, or just the process? To answer that question, let's take a step back and see if companies outside of tech have solved this problem. Life's not so easy in other industries. #2 FMGC companies approach differently At bigger companies like Unilever or P&G, Marketing == Product team. Marketing decides what to build, for whom to build, why to build it, how much to price it, and how to sell it. Sure, sometimes we end up with products that are over-optimized for marketing. Look at any supermarket aisle. But the products sell. They aren't built by one team and then simply handed off to the marketing team to "sell." Revenue and product accountability lies with one team. It's why PMs at Airbnb are accountable for revenue. In tech, product marketing often ends up with the task of "hey, we've built this, now let's get customers." This approach doesn't effectively address demand. #3 Baskin Robbin's 31% Discount Consider another example: Baskin Robbins, the ice cream company, has maintained a consistent message since its founding in 1947. Their logo has always featured the number 31. This number wasn't arbitrarily chosen; it signifies the "31 flavors" concept, offering a different flavor for each day of the month. If a user is well-retained, Baskin Robbins asks them to deepen usage by ordering more of the same flavor (get a tub at a 31% discount). The 31% discount is a clever trigger moment and a time-lapsed deal which, once expired, would require users to wait for about 60 more days. It associates Baskin Robbins with the 31st of each month. Upon closer inspection, Baskin Robbins has effectively implemented: Usage and Frequency Mapping:  Something typically managed by Growth teams today. Trigger Effects:  Leveraging the 31st of each month. Product:  Introducing a new flavor to attract a new niche. Activation:  Encouraging the trial of multiple flavors. You might think this entire strategy [ read case study ] was conceived by someone at Baskin Robbins. However, the idea for "31" actually came from the Carson-Roberts advertising agency (which later became Ogilvy & Mather), in 1953. So, the difference is clear And it makes sense why. Marketers don't understand the possibilities that tech can build. That's why in tech we have product managers. People with the ability to do market research and communicate to devs. So, you have sales, marketing, and growth teams all working on leads. The product team is good at identifying a pain point and making the best possible product in the world. But then, product managers might not have revenue accountability. If it doesn't sell well, the short-term solution is always to market more. Here are some examples of what is written in my college marketing book by Philip Kotler: Growth is essential for the success of any firm. Thus, to be a long-term market leader is the goal of any marketer. Marketers can try to increase the amount, level, or frequency of consumption. (What Reforge Growth courses talk about) In targeting new customers, the firm should not lose sight of existing customers. (Poor line expansion in SaaS). Ironically, some food firms such as Hershey's have developed smaller packaging sizes that have actually increased sales volume. (Pricing and packaging). While trying to expand total market share, the dominant firm must actively defend its current business. Boeing against Airbus. Staples against Office Depot. And Google against Yahoo! and Microsoft. How can the leader do so? The most constructive response is continuous innovation . (Marketing does product management). Six types of defense strategies when you're a dominant firm: position, flank, preemptive, counteroffensive, mobile, contraction (PM work). Market challenger strategies: attact the dominant firm (high risk, high payoff), attack similar sized firms that are not doing the job well, attack regional firms, attack status quo ( lemonade insurance ). Market follower strategies.. and so on.. What you'll notice is that marketing does everything except manage the supply chain. So, it decides what to build, when to build, what to price it at, and where to sell. It does NOT decide how to build it. That resides with the R&D teams and manufacturing plants. Going back to our Intuit case where the bald lady ad failed...maybe the problem isn't with marketing or with the company. It's with the process. The reason why the agency failed is because they didn't quite get it. And they didn't help shape the product. They didn't understand the nuances. And potentially, they might not have been allowed to do so. Who knows? One of the agencies I worked didn't do any research, forget shape the product. They just interviewed clients and delivered work. Things would obviously not perform. I would spend extra time outside work on the weekends to get user research done. Taylor does a good job summarizing the idea: My recommendations If we want to solve this in tech, I've got some recommendations. These are just starting points: 1) Involve growth/marketing early on. Maybe they're called the "Growth" team. But they should be a part of the process much earlier on. It's hard to market a product you don't love or have faith in. 2) Growth/Marketing should understand tech opportunities and limitations in a better way At GitHub, all their marketers know how to code. At Streamline, I took one of the most intensive design courses to speak the same language as our designers. But, I did not put the same effort into learning about frontend/backend terminologies when that would've probably been a more meta skill to develop. 3) Let marketers/growth teams write their own briefs When recruiting agencies, see if they're writing their own creative brief. Mediocre ones will do as you ask them to. Top-tier ones will write their own. A friend of mine shared Ogilvy's campaign brief if you wanted to see how it's done. #4 Ogilvy's Client Brief An example brief for Fanta. Just look at some of the questions. What do they need to know?   Product facts are not usually decisive when people choose between brands, but if they are, list them here, or attach an addendum to the brief. What do they need to feel?   Emotive campaigns usually sell harder. What emotional response are we looking for? (Avoid clichés like “friendly,” “trusted,” etc.) Why should they care?   Brands that address issues bigger than their own category earn more time and attention. Why should people talk about our brand? Marketing has always been doing growth All this growth stuff around A/B testing, in-product tests, statistical significance has been used by marketing teams since ages. Even when there was no tech. Marketing gets a bad rap because, well most marketing is bad. So, I'd say if you worked in marketing/sales/growth or any of these ancillary functions and were laid off, it could because of one or more of these reasons You didn't truly influence the product. You haven't considered the full impact of the marketing lifecycle (awareness, activation, monetization, retention). Or maybe your work wasn't good enough — that's ok! We live and learn :) I'm happy to see that the industry is moving away from spammy marketing and looking at user journeys holistically. If you liked this article, you should read up " The Top 5 Reasons CMOs Get Fired " by Carilu Dietrich who's taken Atlassian public and is an advisor to hypergrowth companies. Thanks for reading! Best, Khushi

  • Sponsoring B2B SaaS Newsletters

    [This article is a WIP. I plan to sponsor newsletters and list down what I learn as I go] Elena Verna The first one I sponsored lately was Elena Verna's newsletter. I learned about PLG from Elena, took most of her courses in Reforge, and followed her to her Growth Scoop newsletter. Writing is actually fun and engaging. Hers alongside Kyle Poyar's Growth Unhinged newsletters are the only ones I read often. I think she and Jonathan on her team truly set the bar on what sponsorships could look like. They truly went above and beyond There were a few things I liked: First, they were able to match our topic with the topic of the newsletter. Second, we even got a featured image with the "Get your free churn reduction analysis". Third, the post linked to another blog post of ours in the article itself. They even honored a second CTA towards the end of the article. My ask was this, Khushi: Can we also have a link at the bottom of the newsletter? Sometimes, I'm so curious about the topic Elena writes about that I want to finish reading it, before I click on an ad. If it's towards the end, there's no other CTA that competes with it for attention. And people won't need to scroll back up. If this list wasn't already enough, they even helped write a blurb for us and gave me feedback on the graphic when it didn't look quite good on the first try. My takeaway is to sponsor posts you already love when you're just starting out as a brand. Then, you can increase your brand awareness budget. I wrote them this message: This partnership is as good as it can get! I could not have asked for anything better. Thank you <3 Our cost was $3000 for this post. It's publicly available here to sponsor . For the second time around, there wasn't enough time to discuss a few items so I had to opt out of sponsoring her newsletter. And Elena just offered it in for free. 🫨 I was playing carrom with my family, celebrating my dad's birthday. And that email came through. It had Churnkey's name at the top. I went through so many emotions all at once. First was an adrenaline rush. I was thinking, "Wow, what an article. Glad we're featured." Then, a little bit of regret followed. "Was I stupid to opt out? This is an incredible article." Then came worry. "Had I messed up the comms and they didn't see we opted out?" Then came relief. "No worries, I'll convince the team to pay and honor it." And it took me 30 minutes to type an email. Before I was done overthinking and rewriting the email again and again, I heard back from her. It said, "it's on the house". What! My jaw just dropped. It wasn't an accident. We were intentionally featured a second time around. This second article of hers was even more popular on social so I definitely would've regretted opting out. Like, a lot. But yeah, it was quite classy and kind of her to do this for us. If you'd like more metrics (click rate etc), I'm happy to share some more of those if you'd like to contact me . Otherwise, you can sponsor her newsletter . There's a lot that you get: a newsletter, a social post, and if you're lucky, maybe that post would be tied in to your topic. The only downside is that the shelf life for a post is around 2 weeks, after which it is behind a paywall. But, I'm clearly biased. I love her content and would do absolutely ANYTHING to be a part of the content she puts out. So, yeah. So far, so good. [Next Post Sponsorship Will Be Updated Here]

  • Hotjar vs Mixpanel — I paid for both

    As a growth lead, I've extensively used Hotjar and Mixpanel for companies of all sizes, including those with millions of users and even small early-stage startups. Here's an in-depth but brain-friendly buying guide.

bottom of page